Gladieux Consulting

  • SERVICES
    • ABOUT
    • MENU (downloadable)
    • 1:1 EXECUTIVE COACHING
    • KEYNOTE SPEAKING
    • STRATEGIC PLANNING
    • TEAM TRAINING
  • CLIENTS
  • KUDOS
  • PRESS
  • COACH’S CORNER
  • GC GIVES BACK
  • RESOURCES
    • FREE TOOLS
    • POCKET 8s
    • RESEARCH SUMMARIES
  • NEWSLETTER

Are performance reviews worthwhile?

I’m not a “praise person”. Is workplace praise a big deal?

Dear Michelle,
Annual performance reviews are approaching. They take up a lot of our managers’ time. Do you think they’re worthwhile?

Yes, absolutely I do, if done with care. If done haphazardly, begrudgingly, with rater bias or by unskilled reviewers, watch out. That’s when return on time investment starts to go downhill. Deborah Tannen, one of my favorite researchers, believes “each person’s life is lived as a series of conversations.” I concur. The once- or twice-yearly 1:1 reviews you have with employees are often the most memorable meetings of their careers. Reviews create a coaching opportunity. It’s your duty and honor to share what you observe about others’ technical and interpersonal skills. Several of our clients report they dislike reviews because it’s uncomfortable to judge. If that’s you, come from a place of humility as you rate others’ work. Acknowledge that you’re still learning, too. A solid review process gives companies a competitive advantage and gets hearts and minds engaged.

Reviews benefit the employer and employee. If an employee exhibits dysfunctional behavior, documenting and discussing what needs to change can set improvement in motion. It protects employers if the employee can’t or won’t change and is asked to leave the organization.

Tips from a recent “Meaningful, Motivating Performance Reviews” seminar:

  • Plan an hour for conversation. Some employees will require more or less time. Use open-ended questions and plan to learn something new.
  • Create a 3-5 item goal plan to conclude each review, and agree on implementation time.
  • Allow your employee a say in goals for the coming review period. We expend more effort when expectations energize and interest us.
  • Include praise and constructive criticism in every review. A true leader doesn’t withhold either. Be candid and specific, and reinforce reasons for employees’ self-esteem.
  • Talk about how your ratings compare to employee self-ratings. Tie discussion to core company objectives.
  • Avoid cut-and-pasting identical goals for employees. Each deserves individual consideration.
  • Steer clear of common rater biases: leniency error (high ratings to avoid conflict), halo effect (high ratings in many categories because of high performance in one), central tendency error (avoiding the high and low end of rating scale) and similarity error (employees in the raters’ in-group receive higher ratings, and vice-versa for the out-group).
  • End the discussion with a positive comment and set a date to review progress on goals.
  • Invite employees to contact you for help, and really mean it. Follow through on an “open-door policy.”

Readers, if you’d like a high-quality blank review format to help with your review meetings, let me know. We’re happy to send it your way at no charge.

Have a question for Michelle and her team?
Fill out the form below and your question may appear in the next Coach's Corner.

Coach’s Corner

  • Is it a big deal if I’m not a “praise person”?
  • I’ve been promoted to supervisor. How do I interact with employees who have always been my peers?
  • How can I stay focused with so much to do?
  • Why do we procrastinate, and what can we do about it?
  • Are performance reviews worthwhile?
  • How can I manage conflict with more confidence?
  • What is “impression management”, and how can we benefit from it?
  • Is work-life balance possible?
  • What’s the best way to deal with a divided team?
  • How can I stay positive in tough times?
  • What’s the best way to make sure trust on our team remains strong?
  • How can I successfully work from home with children present?
  • Is this the best we can expect from people in power?
  • How can I improve my e-mail?
  • What’s involved when an organization pursues process improvement?
  • I’ve been feeling blah about my job, am I ungrateful?
  • What should I expect in strategic planning?
  • My boss gave me a critical review. Am I being set up for termination?
  • How can I deal with an overly-opinionated co-worker?
  • How do you make public speaking look so easy?
  • I feel controlled by my environment. Can I change my mindset?
  • Why do women talk so much?
  • How do I get co-workers to see that words matter?
  • What should I do when there’s no upside at work?
  • What do you teach in conflict management seminars?
  • How can I communicate like an extrovert when I need to?
  • Which quotations inspire you?
  • Do you have any favorite interview questions?
  • Do you think starting a relationship with a coworker is a bad idea?

GET NEWS YOU CAN USE

Sign up for quarterly inspiration + free personal and professional development resources:

Let's connect

We'd love to hear from you.

Give us a call at (260) 450-4202.

Follow us

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • FREE TOOLS
  • LET’S CONNECT
  • Privacy Policy
©2022 Gladieux Consulting All Rights Reserved